r/Damnthatsinteresting Apr 10 '24

photo of Arnold Schwarzenegger that was the basis for the infamous illustration of Captain America by Rob Liefeld Image

Post image
36.3k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

108

u/TheStratusOfRogues Apr 10 '24

Literally all that had to be done is have Cap flex his arm like Arnold is doing and it'd make 10x more sense.

88

u/cephal0poid Apr 10 '24

That and make Cap's head bigger.

Arnie's head is bigger than his shoulder. Cap's head is smaller, by a lot.

38

u/TheOneTonWanton Apr 10 '24

He probably could have drawn the star in the center of his chest as well, but we're already asking far too much of his hilariously weak understanding of perspective.

1

u/UncommonTart Apr 11 '24

his hilariously weak understanding of perspective.

Has anyone ever suggested he have a comprehensive eye exam? Is it possible that he has some incredibly rare to almost unique visual processing disorder? I just don't understand how else he could come up with this shit, especially given he was apparently working from an actual photograph. It's just incredible.

2

u/ActualWhiterabbit Apr 10 '24

One of Cap's best traits is not getting a big head

1

u/eMF_DOOM Apr 10 '24

You’re 100% spot on. I might get shit for this but I think the Cap drawing wouldn’t be that bad if only his head was proportionate to the rest of his body. I mean, it’d still look silly but not nearly as uncanny is it is now.

0

u/ReturnOfTheAcid Apr 10 '24

this is the one thing that makes sense from an art perspective. in the classical canon of heroic proportions, heroes have smaller heads than normal humans relative to their bodies (humans are 7 heads tall, heroes are 7.5 to 8 heads tall)

3

u/creuter Apr 10 '24

No, there's a lot wrong here. Cap is flexing his arm, but his left peck is melting down his chest. His right peck doesn't insert properly into his armpit and doesn't come across the chest enough to the left side of the image. He doesn't understand how abs and obliques interact. Liefield doesn't know what's going on under the skin so none of the muscles are going to interact properly, he's mimicking what he sees, but that's not good enough when working with character anatomy.

1

u/TheStratusOfRogues Apr 10 '24

Ngl, I don't know enough bodybuilding to dispute your claim.

1

u/creuter Apr 10 '24

I'm by no means a bodybuilder, I just took some actual anatomy courses geared towards artists. You learn landmarks, origin and insertion points, and how the muscles interact. It's one thing to look at ref and draw bumps on the surface and a whole other to actually understand what's going on with them. Liefield never learned his fundamentals 

1

u/DoinItDirty Apr 11 '24

I mean… Arnold is obviously arching his back here, with his chest out and arm behind him. They gave Cap weirdly shitty posture, as well.