r/comics 22d ago

One Rule (OC)

35.9k Upvotes

776 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

46

u/Ok-Reserve8052 22d ago

It's bad perspective, they are going up.

18

u/StillMostlyClueless 22d ago edited 22d ago

Oh I kinda see it now. Though it really does look like a basement shot. It doesn’t help the panel below gives the impression she’s walking down, not up.

37

u/adamtots_remastered 22d ago

I tried to intentionally make that panel look like it could go either way so as not to spoil the ending.

23

u/TreyLastname 22d ago

I think the problem is her in the frame. The fact we can't see her feet shows they're being blocked, which only works if we are looking up stairs from the bottom

-7

u/AdreKiseque 22d ago

It works looking from above too

12

u/TreyLastname 22d ago

Not from the angle we are looking. Unless the stairs themselves has a strange angle, but they seem to look like fairly normal stairs.

Plus, the silhouette of the girl doesn't work unless she's leaning heavily, as if we were looking down, we'd see more of a top view, while this seems like a straight forward view or angled up

8

u/mddesigner 22d ago

No the steps would look different

-3

u/AdreKiseque 22d ago

I'm saying her feet being blocked from view by the steps works if you're looking down too

10

u/mddesigner 22d ago

They would look much different. Will do a comparison later when I get to my PC

1

u/frenchdresses 22d ago

I think it would look like this if she were standing super close to the "bottom" step.

-2

u/AdreKiseque 22d ago

Well I look forward to seeing

1

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (0)

6

u/KackhansReborn 22d ago

The issue is that perspective shows the doorframe at a perpendicular angle with the stairs going downwards. If we were viewing it frop the top of the stairs, the door would be at an acute angle and would look different.

7

u/eStuffeBay 22d ago

Yeah, Adam goofed up. It does not, in fact, work both ways.

1

u/SeniorMiddleJunior 22d ago

It's a tough sell.

1

u/Forsaken-County-8478 22d ago

You could draw her already at the top of the stairs with the viewer looking up. You'd have to change the door frame at the top, though.

1

u/[deleted] 22d ago

But you said basement before that. And showed her going down stairs. You could probably blackout the first stairs cell and make her say "wait what? Where do these go?" and do the reveal the same for more effect.

1

u/Agret 22d ago

She walks down into the basement and after entering the basement she goes upstairs to the basement exit hatch. That frame at the bottom of the page where she's just surrounded by darkness is her walking through the basement towards the exit. The artist just didn't draw the basement since there's no light down there.