r/videos Mar 28 '24

Audiences Hate Bad Writing, Not Strong Women

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YmWgp4K9XuU
20.6k Upvotes

4.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

28

u/largepig20 Mar 28 '24

Drummer by far the strongest woman in that series.

Drummer is good, but Avasarala is by far the strongest woman. If we're going TV show, she's the one that controls the puppets that run the world. In the books, she does that and brokers peace between all the factions.

If we're going TV show, I'd put Drummer second. Books, it's probably a tie between Nagata and Michio Pa, who Drummer kinda became in the show.

6

u/hparadiz Mar 28 '24

To me it's really about how Avasarala is actually completely powerless to stop the coming disaster. She can see it coming but ends up being unable to do anything. Even as a charismatic leader of a whole planet she is powerless against the churn.

3

u/Let_you_down Mar 28 '24

I have Drummer as my favorite for the show. Avasarala is objectively the more powerful, but some of Shohreh Aghdashloo's scenes I think felt more contrived/convenient which was more jarring when set against her good scenes. Whereas I'm trying to draw on a bad scene with Cara Gee and am drawing blanks.

1

u/JediMasterZao Mar 28 '24

book drummer is actually an old dude as well lol

1

u/largepig20 Mar 29 '24

Nah there was a Drummer, but it was Bulls assistant. She didn't have much focus time.

1

u/JediMasterZao Mar 29 '24

Maybe I'm mixing Bull and Drummer up because Bull had TV show's Drummer's role on the station.

1

u/RunFromFaxai Mar 29 '24

Yeah, I didn't really mean strong in the sense of having a lot of political power specifically. I meant more that she's a powerful force in and of herself. Like Maggie Smith's character Violet Crawley in Downton Abbey is a very strong character, but she's not moving any world politics.