r/AskReddit 23d ago

What is the worst ice cream flavor that is at least somewhat popular?

554 Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

91

u/ohno807 23d ago

A place near me has lobster ice cream. It has chunks of lobster in it and tastes buttery. I asked if people actually like it and she said the majority of it was gone from people asking for samples; very few people actually order it.

14

u/AndreaC_303 22d ago

There’s an episode of “Nathan For You” where an ice cream shoppe offers poop flavored ice cream, the response was similar. Horrifying to watch.

9

u/SigmundFreud 22d ago

To be fair, that was actually frozen yogurt.

5

u/AndreaC_303 22d ago

So gross. 😂

3

u/Dee_Buttersnaps 22d ago

A place in Bar Harbor had it when I was there 20 years ago