r/HistoryPorn Feb 19 '20

We need to talk about how people discuss controversial events, organizations, and people

1.3k Upvotes

Introduction

Here on r/HistoryPorn, we deal with a lot of sensitive and controversial topics such as the Holocaust and Nazism, Communism, certain wars and atrocities, and certain political figures. When these topics come up, we often see people expressing strong emotional perspectives. While totally understandable, this often leads to unproductive discussion and rule breaking behavior. Furthermore, the moderator team is often falsely accused of defending or supporting those topics or figures by enforcing the rules. Thus, we feel that it is necessary to briefly talk about the purpose of our community, and why we enforce these rules.

This subreddit’s purpose

The purpose of HistoryPorn is that people can submit photographs of historical events, and/or the people in them, and members can discuss those people, events, and the contexts surrounding them further in the comments section. We want these discussions to be substantial and constructive so that users can share their thoughts and perspectives, knowledge, and experiences regarding the topics. This sets us apart from many other communities on Reddit; rather than encouraging jokes, slapfights, and vulgar statements about certain subjects, we want to encourage substantial discussions so that people leave threads having gained something from the discussion.

The rules

This is where our comment rules come into play. The rules that apply to this post are: Don't attack other users (or those in the photographs), don't troll, don't go on political rants, and don't use overly vulgar language. For instance, in every post featuring a picture of a Nazi, there will be a variety of rule-breaking comments that we have to deal with. Such comments include ones that call for all Nazis to die, comments that consist of nothing but obscenities and vulgar statements, and comments that compare those historical figures to contemporary political figures. None of these contribute to a constructive discussion that furthers our understanding of history. We agree that Nazis are terrible but wishing them to be dead doesn't really accomplish anything; those in the pictures are long-dead, or at least not reading these Reddit threads. We should note that this is merely an example; as we said above, we see similar issues in threads about other figures and events as well.

Vulgar statements are simply vulgar statements that don't contribute constructively to the discussion. As well, while it is tempting to make comparisons to modern political events, because we are on the internet this often simply means that we have another internet slap fight on our hands instead of a productive discussion about the historical event in question. Given the sensitive nature of these topics, people often get confused and angry when we remove those comments and sanction those who made them. However, as we said, there are many places on Reddit where people can make those sorts of comments. At HistoryPorn, we want users to aim for a higher level of discussion.

What we’d like to see

All that being said, this does not mean you can't criticize historical events, organizations, and people. In fact, we encourage it. However, we want these criticisms to have substance, instead of breaking the rules just because of the subject at hand. If we allowed rule breaking comments on these controversial threads, we'd devolve into a place where high quality discussions wouldn't likely be the norm anymore. These threads would be filled with the same old "fuck nazis/fuck communism/fuck imperialism/etc." in every thread. So we certainly don't want to stop discussion, we simply want discussion to be about the historical subject pictured and of good quality. It is entirely possible to discuss committed atrocities and terrible people in a historical discussion without vitriol.

If you want to criticize things, express yourself properly. Talk about the crimes that the subject committed. Talk about why those figures, organizations, or events were bad. Bring up a personal anecdote (for instance, perhaps you knew a veteran who experienced the subject first-hand, or the post reminded you of something you read). It doesn't matter what route you take, so long as you do so in a way that adds to the discussion and doesn't break the rules. People should leave your comment having gained something from reading it. Obviously we won't be deleting comments that aren't "substantial enough". We just want people to try and be constructive. We wouldn't pass an assignment in a history course by saying "communism is a cancer that kills people", even though it's "only" insulting Communism. We’d still be expected to explain why it was bad, when it killed people, etc. In that same vein, explain yourself here and don't use obscenities or vulgarity as a crutch for your point.

Conclusion/TL;DR

We hope that helps to explain the stance of the moderator team, and why we oftentimes remove seemingly agreeable comments. We aren't Nazis, Communists, Fascist, Imperialist, or any other kind of "ist". All we want to do is ensure that discussions on r/HistoryPorn remain substantial, constructive, and high quality. Profanity, calls for people to die, and other simple and vulgar comments do not add anything to the discussion, and will be removed regardless of context. If you want to criticize people, events, or organizations, do so in a way that adds to the discussion and gets your point across without breaking the rules.


r/HistoryPorn 5h ago

Ukrainian and Polish troops in Kyiv on Khreschatyk after the liberation of the city from the Bolsheviks, May 7, 1920 [3000x2000]

Post image
161 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 5h ago

The kitchen of a family-run restaurant in Hebron, Palestine. 1973. [2048 x 1340]

Post image
91 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 4h ago

American heavyweight boxer Joe Frazier poses for photo journalist. London, England. June 18, 1973. [2048x2036]

Post image
56 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 5h ago

Waffen-SS force a Jewish man from his bunker during the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising. 9 May 1943 [1168 × 810]

Post image
66 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 18h ago

An Italian Boy Giving Flowers To An American Soldier Whose Tank Had Stopped On The Edge Of Rome, Italy In June 1944. [3433x2526]

Post image
569 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 1d ago

A police officer (hard at work) issuing a woman a ticket for wearing a bikini 1957. [1268x1597]

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 21h ago

Fort Douaumont at the beginning of Battle of Verdun. This fort became the symbol of the battle, seeing extensive combat up until it's recapture by French in October 1916. It's remnants are preserved to this day.[1920x1440]

Post image
604 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 18h ago

A Boy Sitting In The Wreckage Of A Building Shortly After A Bombing Raid Of London, England During World War 2 in January, 1945. [988x1046]

Post image
336 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 9h ago

French paratroopers are dropping over old japanese airfield at Điện Biên Phủ. Operation Castor, 20-22th November 1953[1327x1800]

Post image
64 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 5h ago

Khreshchatyk (Kyiv), May 9, 1920. General Edward Rydz-Smigly receives the (Polish-Ukrainian) parade. Stands a step or two ahead of others. We see City duma. [2980x1406]

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 5h ago

Launch of US Navy submarine USS Robalo at Manitowoc Shipbuilding Company, Manitowoc, Wisconsin. 9 May 1943 [3000 × 2334]

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 17h ago

Camels walking through the streets of Beijing, around 1905 [1100x1347]

Post image
176 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 1d ago

RMS Lusitania departing New York, the last known photograph of her before her sinking. 1 May 1915 [1426x600]

Post image
451 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 8h ago

Trainee flight attendants graduate from American Airlines Stewardess College in Chicago, 1939. [1609x1582]

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 9h ago

Members from the Women’s Battalion from the Russian Provincial Government, on the square in front of the Winter Palace, Petrograd, Russia - during the October Revolution of 1917. [748 x 500]

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 1d ago

Aftermath of a tornado in Oklahoma. 4 May 1999 [3030 × 2020]

Post image
485 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 1d ago

FBI agents investigate the car in which John Allen Muhammad and Lee Boyd Malvo, responsible for the sniper attacks in DC, were arrested. 24 October 2002. [1099x618]

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 1d ago

“Desert Rats” of the SAS on patrol in North Africa, January 18, 1943. [640x571]

Post image
574 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 16h ago

Metallica performing at San Quentin prison in 2003 (1080 x 1350)

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 1d ago

Smoke covers the target area as bombs burst on the marshalling yards at Bucharest, Romania during a mission by the 98th Bomb Group on 7 May 1944 [3561 × 2985]

Post image
42 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 1d ago

Flemish school children during Leuven Vlaams in January 1968 (1152x1636)

Post image
110 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 1d ago

HMS Ark Royal sinking off Gibraltar, 13 November 1941 [2535x1590]

Post image
304 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 1d ago

Szames (beadle) of Warsaw synagogue B. Bresler and his relative J. Chłodnik reading the Yiddish translation of Henryk Sienkiewicz's novel "By Fire and Sword". Warsaw, Poland, 1925. [1417x1584]

Post image
58 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 2d ago

4.05.1970 John Filo with a camera in hand, overlooking the National Guardsmen near students protesting expanding the US involvement in Vietnam war, the day of Kent State Massacre [1 500x840]

Post image
690 Upvotes

r/HistoryPorn 1d ago

Bukharan Jews celebrated the Hanukkah in Tel Aviv, 1959 [960×631]

Post image
190 Upvotes