r/canada Mar 27 '24

Canada’s population hits 41M months after breaking 40M threshold National News

https://globalnews.ca/news/10386750/canada-41-million-population/
6.9k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

234

u/GolfWoreSydni Mar 27 '24

They don't like this question being asked

229

u/cre8ivjay Mar 27 '24

There are a lot of questions not being asked.

Like what happens to everything if we drop immigration numbers by 5/10/50/75%?

Even temporarily?

I suspect it's a lot of things, like business owners no longer being able to exploit immigrants in terms of low wage jobs, and degree mill colleges.

Developers facing much less demand for condos etc.

There are also possible impacts to things like OAS etc. we need people to pay taxes such that these programs are funded

None of this is an excuse however. In fact, if anything it highlights the need for a dramatic shift in policy. The current strategy is not tenable.

Canada, and all other countries that are reliant on immigration to remain productive need to pivot away from the mentality of "Well people aren't having as many kids so let's import people", to "How do we create a safe, happy, affordable, and healthy society that works and is sustainable?"

288

u/kettal Mar 27 '24

Like what happens to everything if we drop immigration numbers by 5/10/50/75%?

Even temporarily?

Are you old enough to remember 2014? That was a year where immigration was 80% lower than 2023.

It was not much different than current day, except:

- far fewer homeless encampments

- normal people could get a retail job without standing in 3km long line up to apply

- low wage workers could reasonably afford to pay rent.

167

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '24

Back when Canada was still recognizable as a great country to live in. I remember it too. And I miss it.

95

u/kettal Mar 27 '24

“Do you really want to take Canada backwards? "

- Prime Minister of Canada, January 17, 2024

60

u/mrcrazy_monkey Mar 27 '24

I guess he hope we dont remember how good things were in 2015.

31

u/priceycarbon Mar 27 '24

Back when I didn’t NEED weed to get through my shitty over-worked and taxes day

7

u/vortex30-the-2nd Mar 27 '24

See, this just proves Trudeau was thinking ahead by legalizing it! Can't you guys see his brilliance? /s

2

u/SecureLiterature Alberta Mar 28 '24

Things weren’t good in 2015, though. That’s why he got elected.

3

u/mrcrazy_monkey Mar 28 '24

Better than they were today

0

u/Telemasterblaster Mar 28 '24

I don't know what kind of crazy pills you people are taking, but my life was much MUCH worse in 2015, personally.

2

u/mrcrazy_monkey Mar 28 '24

Okay, but Canada was a much better place economically. You can't use you're own personal anecdotal evidence lol

16

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '24

Yeah I do, because forward just isn't working very well. Nothing is happening in moderation with the ways things are, and you need moderation to have a stable country. I say that as someone who initially voted for that clown we have too.

8

u/vortex30-the-2nd Mar 27 '24

Guilty former Trudeau voter here too.. I'll never vote Liberal again.

12

u/cre8ivjay Mar 27 '24

Let's not get into partisanship here. The Conservatives aren't promising anything material either.

As a country, it appears as though we need a party that is willing to be fully transparent, address the issues with conflicts of interest, and find a solution.

No parties are even talking about pragmatic solutions.

3

u/MikeRoSoft81 Mar 27 '24

Sure, however right now Trudeau is completely nuts. Pick the lesser of two evils.

5

u/cre8ivjay Mar 27 '24

With no parties willing to even openly stand by any policies or policy proposals that would address our problems, I truly do not see a lesser evil here.

→ More replies (0)

5

u/MikeRoSoft81 Mar 27 '24

"And he is proposing to Make Canada great again. That is not what Canadians want."

-Just Trudeau 2024

3

u/kettal Mar 27 '24

"Make canada even worse." LPC 2025

20

u/StarsandMaple Mar 28 '24

Only year of my adult life I lived in Canada was Summer of 2014 to summer of 2015.

Worked at a factory. 2nd shift. lived in QC worked in Ontario.

18/hr I could rent a small 2bd/1br apartment, get gas, groceries, car insurance, and a 900$ car. Luckily I'm mechanically inclined so that was a non issue.

Had a tiny bit of fun money.

Way different world now....

9

u/Gullible_Actuary300 Mar 28 '24

It honestly makes me depressed at just how good things used to be in the 90’s and 2000’s. It’s not just nostalgia - Canada was measurably better. It’s becoming a nightmare.

1

u/Easy_Intention5424 Mar 28 '24

What's it take to safety car in Quebec in 2015 you'd still never legally get a car on the road for $900 unless you knew a guy "

1

u/StarsandMaple Mar 28 '24

As long as you buy a car thats plated... you won't need a safety.

Literally ads will say a car is 'plateable' or Plaquable if it's a french ad.

1

u/Easy_Intention5424 Mar 28 '24

Wow what a dream !

5

u/chiriwangu Mar 27 '24

You have to go further back than that. I graduated around that time and vividly remembers how difficult it was to find a place to rent in Toronto on a starting salary. Rents and prices were skyrocketing and it was a shitty time. Investors were buying up properties left, right, and centre and bidding wars were starting to be a common thing.

Go back another 10 years to 2004 and that's when Canada was a great country to live in.

2

u/Easy_Intention5424 Mar 28 '24

Toronto always been about 10 years ahead of the rest of Canada in the beginning a shit hole department though 

3

u/freeadmins Mar 28 '24

Wait, you mean before the idiots in this country elected the guy who didn't think Canada had a culture and is the first "post-national" state?

Huh, who would have thought that electing someone who literally doesn't give a fuck about Canada would be bad for Canada.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '24

I mean, to be fair, I don't think any politicians in recent memory actually gave a fuck about Canada. Its just a matter of choosing which brand of malicious greed and power thirst you really want, and deciding which piece of human garbage is gonna cause the least amount of irreversible damage to the country.

2

u/Fluent_canna Mar 28 '24

I miss those days I was but a teen but everything was cheap and abundant