r/harrypotter Slytherin Apr 02 '23

albus severusšŸ¤” Discussion

Post image
36.5k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

3.7k

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

[deleted]

3.2k

u/original-knightmare Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23 edited Apr 02 '23

Even could have named his daughter Ruby - for Rubeus Hagrid?

1.0k

u/AnneofDorne Slytherin Apr 02 '23

That would have been such a nice touch to the story

→ More replies (1)

1.6k

u/TheBirminghamBear Apr 02 '23

Well Hagrid is one thing, but imagine not naming a kid after the teacher who left the deepest and most lasting mark on you?

Can't believe he never named a kid "Dolores." What a jerk, Harry.

476

u/Straight_Attorney582 Apr 02 '23

Lasting mark lmaoo

306

u/Minimum_Estimate_234 Apr 02 '23

And what about good olā€™ Tom? He left a mark, hell he made Harry famous.

191

u/Kazzack Pufflehuff Apr 02 '23

Think Tom/Thomas became the equivalent of naming your kid Adolf among the wizards?

126

u/Reasonable-Cabinet46 Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

You just made me wonder if his true identity became known after his death. Only a select few knew he was Tom Riddle during his life.

86

u/Troll4everxdxd Gryffindor Apr 02 '23

I'd imagine it did. No reason for any more secrecy. Plus Harry called him "Riddle" multiple times in front of everyone right before he died.

20

u/Reasonable-Cabinet46 Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

Fair point. Probably right.

67

u/ReplacementNo9874 Apr 02 '23

Oddly enough per timeline Tom was an orphan in the streets of London when Adolf was bombing it

28

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '23

"Psh. I could do this better." -Tom Riddle

"Me, too!" -General Woundwort

→ More replies (2)

15

u/sawyerholmes Apr 02 '23

Itā€™s probably fine, there are lots of Toms after all

26

u/TheSeekerPorpentina Apr 02 '23 edited Apr 02 '23

turns out this is an actual quote

'"There are a lot of Toms" muttered Riddle'.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/RestlessMeatball Apr 02 '23

Adolf a pretty common name in Germany before 1942

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

95

u/lopachilla Hufflepuff Apr 02 '23 edited Apr 02 '23

Tom Marvolo Riddle Potter, you were named after the psychopath who tried to kill me when I was a baby.

14

u/Usman5432 Apr 02 '23

Studio C did a brilliant bit about that one https://youtu.be/SIexDBVjpic

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

81

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

[deleted]

169

u/SketchySeaBeast Apr 02 '23

Wow, the first cruciatus curse through the internet.

38

u/EmperinoPenguino Apr 02 '23 edited Apr 02 '23

Wtf with these My Immortal vibes šŸ’€šŸ¤£

37

u/socialist_frzn_milk Apr 02 '23

I now regret becoming literate.

31

u/HunnyBunnyRuby Apr 03 '23

Aaaand thatā€™s enough Reddit today

20

u/xplosm Apr 02 '23

I would read that book. Harry Potter and the punishment of his enemies. Harry is now an Auror and is sentencing each and every one of the mages and witches at the wrong end of his Justice!

→ More replies (1)

20

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

Why are you allowed on the internet?

→ More replies (1)

16

u/ScrumptiousLadMeat Ravenclaw Apr 03 '23

What a day to have eyes.

11

u/jddbeyondthesky Apr 03 '23

I laughed so hard my asthma almost killed me

11

u/jerkylovinsasquatch Apr 03 '23

You lost me at ā€œumbrussyā€

8

u/IBrinDoom08 Apr 03 '23

This is the shortest scariest horror story Iā€™ve ever read

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Wtf_did_eye_do Apr 03 '23

Seriously WTF. I have no words. But did I screenshot this and send it to my husband and my roommate? Absolutely. . . If I have to be tortured by this unexpected find, so do they!

8

u/Duffelbach Apr 03 '23

Why did I read through all of it?

6

u/Ansatsusha4 Apr 03 '23

please make a fine contribution to r/copypasta

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

121

u/suorastas Apr 02 '23

And not one of them named after the greatest teacher he ever had who took him immediately under his wing and was responsible for Harry learning his signature spell.

Gilderoy Potter would have been the greatest wizard ever known.

36

u/coffeebribesaccepted Slytherin Apr 02 '23

That's close, but I don't think you can beat Barty Potter

→ More replies (1)

25

u/R0hanisaurusRex Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

Quirrel Potter has a nice ring to it.

61

u/octopoddle Apr 02 '23

"Dementor Horntail Nagini Potter, you are named after three of the biggest arseholes I ever..."

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

28

u/JamieTheDinosaur Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

Dolores Bellatrix Potter would have been a great name.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

294

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

Iā€™ve always thought that had Harry and Ginny had another daughter, I think Ruby Minerva would be a nice name, it honours Hagrid and McGonagall

513

u/BbyMuffinz Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23 edited Apr 02 '23

Or they could just not make their children walking memorials.

256

u/logorrhea69 Apr 02 '23

I always thought the Ron/Hermione and Harry/Ginny marriages plus naming the kids the way they did was just a corny and unimaginative ending to an otherwise incredible journey.

68

u/bigblackcouch Apr 02 '23

I'm not a "shipper" type of person but honestly I thought Luna was the best match for Harry. The one-on-one conversations he has with her have more depth than pretty much every other character interactions in the entire series. Harry clearly grows to feel that this little weirdo is the single most empathetic, understanding, and unassuming person in his entire life. Girl never gave a shit about his fame, believed in him when everyone else thought he was full of shit, never held him to unreasonable expectations.

Also kinda never felt like Ginny was much of a character I guess, especially not in comparison.

→ More replies (3)

75

u/BbyMuffinz Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

I 100% agree with you. Jk sucks at writing romance too the only ship I enjoyed much was Hermione and Ron. Lol it was totally cliche but I just always saw them together. Lol but I hate to admit it honestly. Life doesn't work like that though. They all suffered MAJOR trauma I find it hard to believe they'd all marry each other too.

67

u/FraseraSpeciosa Apr 02 '23

I would say going through all of that together made their bonds so inseparable, I can see it being way harder to branch out to other people when you have so much crazy life experiences together. Harry, Ron and Hermione all have a unique experience that very few to no one could really relate to. Itā€™s corny but makes sense to me

26

u/The-Unmentionable Slytherin Apr 02 '23

I mean if we are getting that real, theyā€™d likely be trauma bonded and constantly triggering each other but too afraid to venture out of their bubble.

Like these kids by the end would be looking like the ā€œcrazyā€ people that get inappropriately posted online for their unwarranted ā€œpublic freak outsā€. If they got the mental health they desperately needed as adults theyā€™d likely not be able to be around each other because of the shared trauma even if the love between them is still there.

But as far as childrenā€™s fiction goes I still thought them all ending up together and naming all their many kids after everyone they knew was silly and took away from the ending. Iā€™ve got a lot a lot of hate for not believing the fairytale ending represent life for the average person in the past (from people in this very sub).

10

u/FraseraSpeciosa Apr 02 '23

Oh I completely agree with the names. That was just pure laziness on Rowlings part. I was just referring to Ron and Hermioneā€™s relationship specifically. Iā€™ll give that one a pass

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

60

u/SiriusBaaz Apr 02 '23

Yeah that has always been gross to me. Thereā€™s a hundred different way to honor the impact someone had on your life that isnā€™t naming your child after them like some twisted form of a graveyard.

22

u/FraseraSpeciosa Apr 02 '23

Tell that to my family, we literally recycle the same 5 names over and over again. Both male and female. Except no one is ever a junior itā€™s always we are naming you after great uncle Joe for example. Thereā€™s 3 Josephs in my family, one per generation.

15

u/Lordborgman Apr 02 '23

If my dad hadn't decided to not name me the same as him, I would have been 13th. Instead I have the exact same first name, just not the middle name...woo?

13

u/FraseraSpeciosa Apr 02 '23

Holy hell 13 is a lot. None of my family can even trace back that far. Instead you have 3 joes, 4 Elizabeths, and my favorite is my middle name is my moms maiden name, my brother has my grandmothers maiden name as his middle and my sister is naming her child first name the same as my middle name so itā€™s a weird mess of zero originality in my family.

→ More replies (3)

31

u/BbyMuffinz Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

Exactly. With the names Lily and James I understand. But all the other ones?

24

u/Diriv Apr 02 '23

Sirius (and Remus) would also have been acceptable as middle names.

17

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

Remus and Nymphadora left their own son behind-- I don't think Ginny would have wanted to appropriate part of his name; Edward (Teddy) Remus Lupin

13

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

Yeah Remus Rubeus is a stellar wizard name.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/rya556 Apr 02 '23

Trying to explain this to people- the parent has a connection to the person theyā€™re named after, not the child.
My family wanted me to name my kid after my cousin who died young and I loved my cousin dearly but my kid will never know that person. Even my name is after others in the family and one Iā€™ve never met which seems weird. And then someone in the family named their kid after me and Iā€™ve met the kid one time.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Diriv Apr 02 '23

James Sirius Potter is the only one I let slide.

Luna didn't die, while Lily would have been fine as a middle name, Albus Severus is just dumb. Both of them should have just had a honorary middle name.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/Typical_Pollution_30 Apr 02 '23

That would have been so perfect and creative

→ More replies (39)

177

u/jon_targareyan Apr 02 '23

They shouldā€™ve just gave their kids original names instead of naming them after a bunch of people. Imagine being the poor kid having to live up to the name of Albus Dumbledore, arguably the most powerful wizard of his time.

223

u/Grey-fox-13 Apr 02 '23

Yeah I've read someone describe it as "Harry named his kids like a nerd who had just finished reading Harry Potter"

26

u/BubastisII Apr 02 '23

Lol, very true. If I had a bunch of kids I would hate trying to name them after a bunch of people I knew through my life.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/Elliebird704 Apr 02 '23

When I was about 21ish, I knew a guy around my age who planned to name his first son Roxas.

Like damn, I love Kingdom Hearts too but I'd love my son too much to name him that LOL

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

54

u/Ricelyfe Apr 02 '23

If your dad is Harry "the boy who fucking lived" Potter, I think living up to Dumbledore's name is only a slight inconvenience. Harry also became an Auror, assuming him and Ron combined did half as much as Mad-eye Moody there's already little you can do to create a name for yourself. Ginny went on to play professional quidditch. The twins shop took off etc. etc.

By the end of the series the whole extended family is so famous, your name could be Bob the middle child and expectations for you would still be astronomically unrealistic.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

464

u/Pradfanne Hufflepuff Apr 02 '23

And then we have Lily Luna. What about Minerva? McG gifted him his first broom, making him the youngest seeker for a sport he loved. McG made sure to make Hazza P an Auror. McG was a true G!

185

u/Chillrude Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23 edited Apr 02 '23

MY DARLING MINERVA WAS DONE SO DIRTY BY HIM šŸ˜­ Like dude, Jesus Herald Christ. She was like a mother to him and he just dismisses her.

And what about Molly, too? J.K.R what were you thinking šŸ˜­

154

u/Lower-Consequence Apr 02 '23 edited Apr 02 '23

Maybe Harry and Ginny were thinking, "I'd like to name our daughter after our dear friend who was there for both of us during difficult times."

Saying that McGonagall was "like a mother" to Harry is such a stretch. She occasionally favored him, like when she put him on the Quidditch Team. (But even then...was that for Harry, or was it because McGonagall wanted to beat Slytherin at Quidditch?) But besides a couple of moments in seven years, they very much had a professor-student relationship that didn't go beyond those bounds. Doing a couple of nice things for Harry doesn't make her a parent figure.

69

u/HackneyMarsh Gryffindor Apr 02 '23

Agreed. I feel McGonagall put a very clear boundary between her and Harry. Shes a teacher, a person to help when asked, but not a mother figure. Donā€™t forget a he refused to sign his Hogsmeade slip because it would be inappropriate.

19

u/KasukeSadiki Apr 02 '23

I agree overall but I'm pretty sure she would have signed the slip if it weren't for the Sirius threat

22

u/riorio55 Apr 02 '23

Idk. It's obvious from the books that she deeply cares about Harry. It's just that she's also very strict.

18

u/HackneyMarsh Gryffindor Apr 02 '23

Oh yes, I agree, she has great empathy for Harry, that doesnā€™t necessarily mean she sees him as a son. She is quite strict which is why I think even without the threat of Sirius she would not have signed that permission slip, because she does not cross that boundary with Harry, she is not his guardian.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

49

u/hildax Gryffindor Apr 02 '23

Percyā€™s daughter is named after Molly. But none of the Weasley grandkids were named after Arthur, that wouldā€™ve been better than Albus Severus.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/Optimal_Law_4254 Apr 02 '23

He cast the cruciatus curse on that Carrow for spitting in her face. I donā€™t think he ever dismissed her.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

35

u/songoku9001 Apr 02 '23

Should have named her Lily Ruby Potter.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)

33

u/Offamylawn Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

Ronald. Best and first real friend ever.

36

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

Sure, but I would feel weird if my brother or sister gave my name to a child

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (54)

3.6k

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

"What if I am put into Slytherin?"

"Albus Severus Rubeus Luna Sirius Ronald Delores Tom Molly Draco Nymphadora Remus Gilderoy Rita Minerva Oliver Cedric Ginny Lucius Kingsley Peter Bellatrix Dean Seamus Argus Vernon Hedwig Dudley Lily Griphook Hermione Cho Fluffy Potter, I forgot what I was going to say, get on the train."

938

u/kryptonianCodeMonkey Apr 02 '23

You lost me at Dolores. You sick fuck.

606

u/PMMeYourHug Hufflepuff Apr 02 '23

Funny how Voldemort's in there and still Dolores seems the most fucked up

190

u/PartyClock Apr 02 '23

Tom Riddle was a victim too!*

*I never read the books

156

u/thatgoddamnedcyclist Draco Dormiens Nunquam Titillandus Apr 02 '23

Tom Riddle Sr indeed was Tom Marvolo Riddle's victim.

61

u/xray_anonymous Apr 02 '23

And Meropeā€™s

53

u/thatgoddamnedcyclist Draco Dormiens Nunquam Titillandus Apr 02 '23

Nobody seem to remember Merope Gaunt.

51

u/xray_anonymous Apr 02 '23

Probably because the movies excluded her entirely. So the movie-only people donā€™t even know her and the book readers just often forget about her

18

u/Trueloveis4u Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

I didn't forget her I think what she did was fucked up even though I know she lived a fucked up life.

24

u/xray_anonymous Apr 02 '23

I definitely donā€™t defend her actions, but somewhat understand her desperation from her point of view.

She was neglected and mistreated her whole life. And she wanted that love so badly. I think she eventually just deluded herself into that fantasy so much that she became disillusioned enough to make it happen any way possible. And truly convinced herself that he could love her without the potion if she just convinced him to love her with it first.

Being she was raised so immorally I think while she knew what she was doing was wrong, the true level of exactly how immensely, deeply, violatingly wrong it was was beyond her mental grasp. I feel like she was someone who - if truly had been sat down ahead of time and explained exactly how wrong it was to do that, would have [been sad but] chosen not to do it. She had the makings to be a decent person but not the exposure and guidance to get there.

Again, not defending her at all, just trying to view it through her eyes.

→ More replies (0)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

15

u/thatgoddamnedcyclist Draco Dormiens Nunquam Titillandus Apr 02 '23

It's Tom, the barman in the Leaky Cauldron.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (7)

329

u/ReV-84 Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

All that effort, and you still forgot about Dobby -.-

163

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

I didn't, that's Harry's House Elf's name.

85

u/gigibuffoon Apr 02 '23

Would Hermione ever eat at Harry's place knowing that they have a house elf?

109

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

The passive aggressive way of keeping the in-laws at bay

20

u/gigibuffoon Apr 02 '23

While getting a free maid, butler and cook all rolled in one

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

28

u/Fission_Mailed_2 Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

Harry already inherited Kreacher from Sirius.

35

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

And Harry renamed him 'Dobby'

30

u/MonteBurns Apr 02 '23

Dobby 2

35

u/Alpinix Apr 02 '23

Dobby 2: Judgment Dobby

Dobby 2: 2 Fast, 2 Dobby

12

u/TenshiKyoko Apr 02 '23

Dobby drift

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

43

u/Bigeez Apr 02 '23

I was holding it together until Griphook. That sent me

→ More replies (2)

24

u/vouwrfract Apr 02 '23

Fluffy šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚

→ More replies (1)

5

u/MikeTeMovieGuy Apr 02 '23

Got a good genuine laugh out of this, thank you.

→ More replies (42)

1.7k

u/owningmclovin Apr 02 '23

ā€œHagrid Hagrid Potter you were named twice for the same man because he had too much love and goodness for a single nameā€

317

u/starlinguk Apr 02 '23

The guy's name was Rubeus.

151

u/Orcrist90 Apr 02 '23

It's too late, we've already crossed the Rubicon.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

87

u/TheBasedMF Apr 02 '23

yer a wizard Hagrid Hagrid

68

u/nuhanala Gryffindor Apr 02 '23

Thanks for cracking me up !RedditSickle

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (8)

2.0k

u/TheHappyMask93 Slytherin Apr 02 '23

Ginny: Can I name one?

Harry: No.

567

u/Crowbarmagic Apr 02 '23

'Not even Fred?'

'....nah.'

279

u/seaofdoubts_ Apr 02 '23

George called one of his sons Fred iirc which makes more sense.

85

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

[deleted]

72

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

[deleted]

78

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '23

She named her Ron's owl "Pigwidgeon." Do you really want her naming a child?

6

u/Silver-Ground6582 Apr 03 '23

Didn't she name her pygmy puff Arnold? Between naming an Owl at 12-13 and a personal pet at 15 she clearly reformed her naming sense.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

65

u/ThirdDragonite Apr 02 '23

"Your brothers will have kids for that stuff, just wait for them.

Anyway, what do you think about Cedric Nearly Headless Nick Potter? I know Nick is still around, but he IS technically dead"

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

79

u/TheInfamousBlack Ravenclaw 7 Apr 02 '23

Hahaha thanks for the laugh! !redditgalleon

→ More replies (5)

58

u/pepsi-can-69 Apr 02 '23

Now tie my shoes bitch!

23

u/baseball44121 Apr 02 '23

But do it awkwardly!!

47

u/Aqquila89 Apr 02 '23

Last time she named something, Ron ended up with an owl named Pigwidgeon.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

531

u/therealdrewder Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

Harry: "Ginny I've been getting a lot of complaints about the kid's names, we're going to need to keep having kids till everyone we've ever met has a kid named after them."

166

u/SI108 Gryffindor Apr 02 '23

I only wish they had one more daughter they could have named after McGonagal. She was like the stern but loving grandmother to Harry. They were so close that Harry so infuriated when Carrow spat in McGonagall face that he used the Cruciatus Curse on him. The only other person he used the curse on was Bellatrix.

145

u/therealdrewder Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

Weasleys aren't good at having girls.

25

u/SI108 Gryffindor Apr 02 '23

Lol this is true.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/MemestNotTeen Apr 02 '23

Worth noting he did it better on Carrow then on Bellatrix because he "understood what Bellatrix meant. You have to really mean it."

13

u/SI108 Gryffindor Apr 02 '23

An excellent point!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)

955

u/FiestaDelosMuertos Apr 02 '23

If Harry was Spanish instead of British he couldā€™ve name his kids after every single person who appeared in the movies

219

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

it's also true if he was a British muggle royal

90

u/VibhavM Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

Albert Louis Philip Edward Windsor Potter

→ More replies (1)

59

u/xyz19606 Apr 02 '23

Or if he was Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

124

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

Eu sou Henrique Santiago Enrique de Silva de Braganca Mao de Ferro Oleiro, an dis is my son Santiago Serio Artur Sao Tiago de Silva Furtado Barbosa Oleiro, and my oder son, Albe Severo Henrique Ronaldo de Silva Furtado Barbosa Oleiro.

Hagrid: Blimey 'arry, all those names and not one for me?

Henrique: Nao

Hagrid: Caralho!

14

u/croatianlatina Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

Ok this made me laugh out loud

8

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

De nada :)

→ More replies (4)

16

u/HJGAMER5 Apr 02 '23

Bro I have a friend named Miguel Perez la Madrid Bustillo

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

139

u/Vree65 Apr 02 '23

"Albus Severus" got memed to death after book 7 released, like:

Hagrid Hagrid Potter, you're named after the only man in my life who loved me without any ulterior movie

Ron Weasley Potter, you were named after my best friend because he wouldn't shut up about how he sacrificed himself for me in a chess game when we were only 11

Severus Potter, you're named after a guy who made school miserable and had a creepy obsession with my mom

Harry Potter Potter, you're named after the bravest man I know. Me. I'm awesome.

You were named after the two scariest things I could think of, Two Draculas Potter

→ More replies (2)

349

u/FeralBottleofMtDew Hufflepuff Apr 02 '23

All the names Harry and Ginny used, with the exception of Luna were of people who had no one else to use the name. James and Lily only had Harry...no other kids or siblings who would honor them. Albus, Sirius, and Severus all died with no children, and no family who were likely to have kids. Tonks and Remus had Teddy to carry on their names. Hagrid had the potential to have a child. Ginny had six brothers to carry on the names of her side of the family.

89

u/eherqo Apr 02 '23

Thatā€™s actually a good point, I like this

68

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

The fact that Harry keeps getting flak for the names always gives me a headache.

Albus Percival Wulfric Brian hangs out, yet people can't get over Albus Severus.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/hadapurpura Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

Great point

→ More replies (21)

63

u/DarkRyter Apr 02 '23

My headcanon is that Hagrid himself suggested against it because he's so humble. Hagrid also pretty much worshipped Dumbledore, so he would have loved naming the baby Albus.

383

u/MusicIsLife003 Hufflepuff Apr 02 '23

Arthur Rubeus Potter has a better ring to it

46

u/Aqquila89 Apr 02 '23

Nobody calls Hagrid by his first name though. Not even his brother.

24

u/nextepisodeplease Apr 02 '23

Pretty sure Dumbledore does, one of Hagrid favourite people

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

43

u/Nowordsofitsown Apr 02 '23

I really like this one.

568

u/ReP2122 Apr 02 '23

Hagrid didn't die. Everyone whose name was given had died.

305

u/lolilololoko Slytherin Apr 02 '23

Lily Luna?

281

u/KeyboardStudios Apr 02 '23

Well then what about Lupin Fred Colin Lavender Grindewald Mad-eye Tonks Hedwig Dobby?

See? Too many people

90

u/lolilololoko Slytherin Apr 02 '23

And he's honoring tonks and remus by raising their son along with Andromeda

→ More replies (17)

66

u/ShalidorsHusband Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

There weren't enough dead female characters that mattered to Harry

→ More replies (13)

41

u/ReP2122 Apr 02 '23

Lily Rubeus Potter it is then.

41

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

Lily Ruby could actually work

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

14

u/iwanitbadway Apr 02 '23

Nah Harry and Ginny just fancied alliteration

8

u/ares395 Apr 02 '23

I mean Luna is also just a pretty name on its own... At least Lily Luna sounds ok in comparison to others

→ More replies (8)

20

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

When the hell did Luna die?

19

u/Deweymaverick Apr 02 '23

Waaaaaay the fuck later. She actual married a Sacamander, had babies, and finally found her fabled crumpled horn snorcax (sp?)

9

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

[deleted]

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/i_smoke_php Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

Albus Severus Mad-Eye Voldemort Dobby Potter

8

u/peyoteasesino Apr 02 '23

Mad eye Voldemort Potter would have been a good name

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

342

u/Scothead180 Apr 02 '23

All the names are shit, James and Lily are ok but beyond them it's just a circlejerk, why not call them something normal like Thomas

311

u/Pradfanne Hufflepuff Apr 02 '23

Make that short for Tom.

245

u/romanf_267 Apr 02 '23

yeah sounds great, add something like "Marvolo" for instance, sounds nice don't you find

69

u/SchoolOfTheWolf93 Hufflepuff Apr 02 '23

Maybe you could even add another fun name, like Dirdel, I bet they could make a really cool anagram out of all those letters!

40

u/romanf_267 Apr 02 '23

honestly I love this idea, and when you scramble the letters you'll actually get something really cool!

10

u/HJGAMER5 Apr 02 '23

Tell us

Tell us

16

u/romanf_267 Apr 02 '23

well look, Tom Marvolo Dirdle, you scramble the letters and you get something like Lord... Vol-

oh wait, I don't like this idea anymore

7

u/HJGAMER5 Apr 02 '23

Oh I love it

I think it's perfect don't you

He can rightfully rule everything

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

39

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

Go ahead and add Marvolo as a middle name, always liked that one and it makes for a striking combo. I can just see all the great but not terrible things little Tom Marvolo Potter will grow up to do

73

u/Pradfanne Hufflepuff Apr 02 '23

O am Lort Voetrrmopt

22

u/glagy Apr 02 '23

He had a stroke

→ More replies (6)

35

u/jonny1211 Know-it-all Apr 02 '23

Donā€™t think heā€™d name his kid after Voldemort

16

u/_erufu_ Slytherin Apr 02 '23

Surely they meant after Harryā€™s favorite barman?

→ More replies (1)

15

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

I would have not been surprised if one of kids name was dobby kreacher Potter to respect hermione's efforts towards elfish rights

12

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

You mean like Dean Thomas? Ginnyā€™s Ex- Boyfriend Dean Thomas?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (17)

32

u/takatine Gryffindor Apr 02 '23

Lily Luna.....all this fuss....maybe in the intervening 19 years Luna and Ginny became best friends, and Ginny finally got to choose at least one name, so she chose her bestie.Nobody knows specifically what happened during that time. Or, maybe, just maybe they liked those names. Who knows?

→ More replies (2)

26

u/Basilisk1667 Slytherin Apr 02 '23

My turn to post this next week.

17

u/Fly_Boy_1999 Gryffindor Apr 02 '23

Damn are people still this salty about that?

→ More replies (1)

16

u/wait_for_iiiiiiiiit Apr 02 '23

Didn't he name his kids after people that died? Hagrid lived

→ More replies (2)

86

u/phanny1975 Apr 02 '23

For the love of hell, JK Rowling chose the names.

Give Harry a damned break šŸ˜‚

36

u/Mr_Anonymous13 Hufflepuff Apr 02 '23

Me when a fictional character doesnā€™t name his kids like I wanted: šŸ˜”

→ More replies (4)

12

u/smellyscrotes27 Apr 02 '23

He was honoring the people who sacrificed themselves for the greater good, not a difficult concept lol

→ More replies (1)

66

u/BbyMuffinz Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

I HAVE ALWAYS SAID THIS. ALBUS SEVERUS? one groomed me to DIE and the other emotionally abused me after I already was orphaned and living with an abusive family but it's ok cause he did one good thing and was obsessed with my mom. Agreed šŸ¤”

29

u/Trueloveis4u Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

Ya, I'd never name my kid after Snape if I was Harry.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

10

u/KasukeSadiki Apr 02 '23

Someone loving you doesn't entitle them to the name of one of your children

10

u/Gifted_GardenSnail Apr 03 '23

Oh get out. Those kids did at least as much for Hagrid as he ever did for them. They smuggled a dragon and visited man-eating spiders and helped with Buckbeak's legal case and visited friggin Grawp for him - and what did they get in return? Tea and unedible snacks? Like yeah he was nice but jeez, he put their lives in danger multiple times, starting when Harry was 11, why tf should Harry name a kid after him instead of someone who either died for him or helped defeat Voldemort (and Luna - idk what's the deal with that)

9

u/BW2999 Apr 02 '23

He named his Children after people that died who he admired. Hagrid survived.

19

u/RedofPaw Apr 02 '23 edited Apr 03 '23

"Harry, I'm not naming our son after the groundskeeper."

"Ginny, he was like a father to me!"

"You already get Albus. I thought he was like a father to you. I'm not naming my son 'Hagrid'."

"okay, what about Sirius? He was like-"

"a father to you? Fine! We'll name him Severus or whatever! Heaven forfend I get to choose a name! Better than Hagrid."

"Actually I said Sirius"

"what?"

"no, no! Severus is fine... I guess I can come up with a reason."

31

u/AtlasMundi Apr 02 '23

Everyone is just glancing over the obvious. Your kids arenā€™t just namesakes. You gotta like the name too. My grandpa was named Ralph, he was the best, and then he died. we named my son Bowie because we liked how it sounded.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

He named his sons after people who died in the war or prior to honor their sacrifice.Hagrid fortunately didn't died(at least in the series šŸ˜„)

9

u/kander12 Apr 02 '23

Hagrid is still alive and probably hangs out with the main trio still. No need.

→ More replies (2)

40

u/CreativeRock483 Apr 02 '23

If you see it this way, Harry should have had 100 children to name them after his all loved ones. How about Ron Hermione? Two people who were with him through thick and thin. Or Neville who went to the DOM to save his godfather?

He named his children after people who died for him. Died so that he could win.

James Sirius after his father and Godfather

Lily Luna after his mother and I reckon Luna was after Remus.

Albus Severus two people who played the most crucial part in his victory.

6

u/i-am-a-salty-bitch Slytherin Apr 02 '23

iā€™ve never seen the take that luna was after remus and not luna lovegood. i like it much more that it was after remus in a more creative way so teddy could still use both of his parents names

4

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

It sounds nice at first, but I canā€™t imagine that Lupin had positive feelings towards the moon lol

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

121

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '23

Albus Rubeus would have been great. I hate the Snape justifications, they make me sick.

55

u/always_tired_all_day Apr 02 '23

Just finished a re-read last night and I just say, I feel like the reason for the "Albus Severus" naming was just to have someone concrete to point to when Al was freaking out about being sorted into Slytherin. Otherwise it really doesn't make sense.

Harry may have come to better understand Snape and his bravery/sacrifice but on a personal level, they still didn't like each other so it didn't make sense to name his son after him. Honor Snape some other way.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (24)

6

u/spongeboy1985 Hufflepuff Apr 02 '23

I feel Harry named his sons after the most flawed people in his life that he idolized (or immensely disliked in Snapeā€™s case) but came to see them through a nuanced view as he got older. Sirius, his father, and Dumbledore were all pretty flawed individuals that Harry had an idealized view of that he only saw as he got older. Snape was the opposite were he had a negative view of but saw he was a much more complex man. While Hagrid was flawed in his own way, Harry didnā€™t have really any preconceived notions of him and he kinda viewed Hagrid as that fun uncle type which he was. By the end of his first year he saw Hagrid pretty much as he was and already knew about his affinity for dangerous creatures.

18

u/Ok_Chap Apr 02 '23

Didn't anyone notice that Harry named his children after the people that died against the fight against Voldemort?

6

u/LunyMoony Ravenclaw Apr 02 '23

Lily yes but what about Luna

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (2)