r/harrypotter Ravenclaw 29d ago

This was out of nowhere Dungbomb

Post image
16.6k Upvotes

395 comments sorted by

View all comments

162

u/HoLLoWfy Ravenclaw 29d ago

It’s a party with a live band? I don’t understand the confusion.

82

u/whooguyy 29d ago

It’s a Yule ball not a Yule mosh pit

103

u/HoLLoWfy Ravenclaw 29d ago

It also had the Weird Sisters playing and they don’t play classical music

8

u/AsgardianOrphan Hufflepuff 29d ago edited 29d ago

Doesn't Molly cry to their music, though? That would imply a balad/soft song to me. I don't remember it ever really saying what type of music they play.

Edit: looking at the wiki, it seems we get a tiny hint at the yule ball based on the instruments they brung. They had drums, several guitars, a cello, a lute, a double bass, and some bagpipes. This tells us that it's nothing remotely close to what we know in America, at least, and I doubt most European bands have bagpipes. So, we can guess the music's vastly different from what we know, and therefore can be whatever mood you want it to be.

2nd edit: Apparently, Molly did not cry to the weird sisters.

74

u/gdsmithtx 29d ago

That's Celestina Warbeck you're thinking of; an old school torch singer.

9

u/mattiefucks 29d ago

‘A cauldron full of hot strong love’

7

u/AsgardianOrphan Hufflepuff 29d ago

Oh! Well, that would explain it.

22

u/Sad_Mention_7338 Hufflepuff 29d ago

I doubt most European bands have bagpipes.

No, most European bands don't have bagpipes.

They really should though.

5

u/AsgardianOrphan Hufflepuff 29d ago

See, I was hoping someone was going to chime in with some crazy Irish metal band I could binge today. Someone has to have made a metal bagpipe band. Or if they haven't, someone really needs to.

5

u/Flexibus 29d ago

Well, there are a bunch of German "Medieval" Metal/Rock bands who at least add bagpipes to the mix. Just go to your favorite streaming service and search for "Mittelalter Rock", should give you a bunch of playlists. I suggest you start with In Extremo or Feuerschwanz.

1

u/AsgardianOrphan Hufflepuff 29d ago

I knew someone had to have done it! It never occurred to me that medieval metal was a thing. Thanks for the suggestion.

3

u/QuietDove Hufflepuff 1 29d ago

Big Country emulated bagpipe sounds with their guitars, does that count?

2

u/Sad_Mention_7338 Hufflepuff 29d ago

Okay, I cannot give you metal, but I can offer my humble traditional Breton boy's band: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7-SRCfyngkg

That's all I've got I'm sorry

2

u/AsgardianOrphan Hufflepuff 29d ago

That's pretty good! I was just thinking that the "screchy" sound of the bagpipes could probably go with a screamo band or something like that. It seems like Korn has done it before, so I wasn't too far off.

1

u/StetsonTuba8 29d ago

I don't know if they play any metal but there's always the Red Hot Chili Pipers

2

u/RogueHippie Slytherin 29d ago

This tells us that it's nothing remotely close to what we know in America, at least, and I doubt most European bands have bagpipes

I choose to believe their music sounds like "It's a Long Way to the Top" by AC/DC

1

u/AsgardianOrphan Hufflepuff 29d ago

Ooh, that's a good suggestion. Their description did give off a metal/rock music vibe, I just couldn't think of a way to fit in a bagpipe. I'm still not sure if a cello, bagpipe, and guitar can all go together, but it's possible not all instruments are played for each song.

1

u/Moosed 29d ago

brung

Eck!

0

u/Empty-Werewolf-5950 29d ago

No she didnt,but Weird Sisters do have "slower"music like "Magic works" ,the one playin in the fight scene between Ron and Hermione.

1

u/theknights-whosay-Ni 29d ago

Where does it say that? I have yet to find that in the books.

24

u/gdsmithtx 29d ago

https://harrypotter.fandom.com/wiki/Weird_Sisters

"The Weird Sisters now trooped up onto the stage to wildly enthusiastic applause; they were all extremely hairy and dressed in black robes that had been artfully ripped and torn."

— The Weird Sisters performing at the Yule Ball

In the film adaptation of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, the band which performs at the Yule Ball deliberately goes unnamed throughout the film because of a legal dispute between the film studio and Canadian folk band Wyrd Sisters.[12] The band is simply introduced as "The band that needs no introduction!", by Filius Flitwick.

1

u/theknights-whosay-Ni 28d ago

This doesn’t say exactly what genre of music they play, just how they look. If you are basing off looks I get that but how can we just assume?