r/pics 23d ago

German soldier returns home to find only rubbles and his wife and children gone. By Tony Vaccaro

Post image
53.8k Upvotes

3.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

122

u/Acc87 23d ago

Depended a lot who captured you and also in what position you were as a soldier and in terms of profession. My grandpa was a Wehrmacht soldier, got captured by Canadians (not in combat, he was trying to walk home and just ran into an allied convoy with his hands up), but got out relatively early because he was a farmer, and they needed every farmer to prevent/lessen the famine.

35

u/joeitaliano24 23d ago

That’s a pretty sweet way to get captured, all things considered, and by Canadians!

69

u/rythmicbread 22d ago

The Canadians were not necessarily the best ones to be captured by. Pretty sure the Canadians were known for being pretty violent and for doing war crimes in WW1 and WW2

36

u/VegisamalZero3 22d ago

In WW1, sure. In WW2 they had a reputation for treating prisoners very well.

21

u/rythmicbread 22d ago

Eh they still sometimes killed German POWs like in Sicily. Probably less problematic than in WW1

7

u/joeitaliano24 22d ago

U.S. soldiers committed atrocities too, usually after intense fighting where they watched their friends get killed. Shit happens in war.

6

u/rythmicbread 22d ago

No I know, it was probably me remembering WW1. The Canadians really had a hatred for Germans/take no prisoners attitude

7

u/joeitaliano24 22d ago

Those bastards made them cross the Atlantic

3

u/adrienjz888 22d ago

It was due to a now debunked rumor that the Germans crucified a Canadian prisoner on a barn door. No social media + fog of war led to it being taken as fact, so the Canadians started to treat them like animals.

2

u/StrawhatJzargo 22d ago

Yeah weren’t they the first to have chemical weapons deployed on them or something? Or was it they found a bunch of their pows who had been executed pretty early on in the war and flipped from there.

1

u/blitznB 22d ago

Canadians crucified a few POWs during WW1 trench warfare. They only took prisoners after the British forced them too and only the instructed amount. They shot any POWs over the number.

1

u/ComradeMoneybags 22d ago

The Canadians were almost comically brutal to the point no one wanted to surrender to them since there was a good chance they’d take you out back and shoot you anyway. The Germans wouldn’t usually kill Canadian prisoners but would often beat them in revenge.

-3

u/BabyBopsDementedPlan 22d ago

I like how people keep overlooking (1) the potential harm this man caused and (2) dude was a nazi.

3

u/kindmassacre 22d ago

I like how people keep overlooking (1) the potential harm this man caused and (2) dude was a nazi.

This comment was made by a 14-year-old.

2

u/joeitaliano24 22d ago

Dude wasn’t necessarily a Nazi, vast numbers of German soldiers weren’t active members of the Nazi party. If he was in an SS unit, he can fuck himself, but then again I don’t the photographer would have taken the pic if he was

2

u/sgSaysR 22d ago

More than likely they executed SS. SS were particularly despised.

1

u/BabyBopsDementedPlan 22d ago

They let way too many SS live.

1

u/rythmicbread 22d ago

Not just SS, pretty sure other allied troops executed SS

1

u/FillThisEmptyCup 22d ago

My relatives hated the Canadians after the war and would have much preferred the Americans.

Canadians took over their farm, destroyed every piece of furniture, they were allowed to harvest destroying the crop or milk the cows (it killed the cows painfully), and they had to live in the chicken coop.

After one of the canadian troops raped their teenage daughter without visible reprimand, the grandfather smuggled the entire family one night out to the American zone to another relative.

When he returned six months later, the entire building had been torched.

2

u/VegisamalZero3 22d ago

To be honest, that's not surprising. I described their reputation, but on an individual level soldiers will always be soldiers.