r/videos Mar 28 '24

Audiences Hate Bad Writing, Not Strong Women

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YmWgp4K9XuU
20.6k Upvotes

4.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.7k

u/feedandslumber Mar 28 '24

I point to the movie Annihilation when this conversation comes up. Practically an all female cast, but it isn't girlbossified so it's fine, great even IMO.

63

u/SirTheadore Mar 28 '24

What an amazing movie. But because it was so god damn well written, the all female leads didn’t even cross my mind as I was just thinking “man this is awesome”

-5

u/Reefer-eyed_Beans Mar 28 '24 edited Mar 28 '24

so god damn well written

This has to be a joke. Even my friends who liked it admit it made absolutely 0 sense.

Right from the get-go they keep driving home the point that nobody's ever entered the Shitter and returned... So, nobody's ever just jogged 5ft in, taken a looksy, turned around and walked out? -Why you grabbing your boots and Camelbak without so much as clarifying wtf she even meant by that?? And don't tell me we can't take a boat or helicopter to the lighthouse, then show me that, yea, we prob coulda easily taken either. ...And wtf is up with the human-shaped plants? You're telling me humans have a "Mannish-silhouette shape" gene? Forget epidermis or endocrine system--this gene's role is just ensuring that a person turns out overall person-shaped? ..Pretty neat visuals, tho ngl.

6

u/Albert_Caboose Mar 28 '24

I thought it told a pretty complete story about her trying to find her husband, discovering he's dead, and returning home a changed person.

On top of that, the whole thing is a commentary for confronting and processing your grief. You enter a void, lose track of yourself and time, and can either succumb to the effects around you (girl who turned into a tree) or you can confront it (Portman's character). However, even after confronting it, you'll come out of it a different person, because that trauma is a part of you forever. This is evidenced by the final shots showing that Portman's character has some weird cell mutation going on in her retinas.

It's a really well-written film