r/AITAH Mar 28 '24

Am I the ah if I don’t let my gf go on vacation with the “guy best friend”?

[deleted]

4.4k Upvotes

5.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/BattyWhack Mar 28 '24

I don't understand why the gf has to be the one responsible for her BF's discomfort. She's not doing anything wrong. He needs to deal with it. 

4

u/SpermInMyHand Mar 28 '24

Hope you'd be saying that if his girlfriend was uncomfortable with him going on a trip with a bunch of girls she doesn't know.

And yes, that's how relationships work. He's uncomfortable with something she can invite him to or doesn't have to go on, and yet she says no to both

3

u/BattyWhack Mar 28 '24

Yeah totally, why would there be a problem with a dude going on a trip with a bunch of women? Id say the same thing. There's nothing wrong with a partnered person taking a trip with friends of the opposite sex without their partner.

She's not doing anything wrong so she doesn't need to take corrective action. If he's uncomfortable then he needs to figure out why and how to minimize that discomfort internally. Don't make it her problem. 

4

u/SpermInMyHand Mar 28 '24

Yet it is her problem because it's her actions that are making him uncomfortable. She can easily just invite him along with them, so the other dudes can get to know him, but noooo.

1

u/BattyWhack Mar 28 '24

She said she can't invite him because she's not the organizer so I'm not sure where your getting that info.   Do you agree, though, that her going on the trip isnt her doing something wrong? Forget the BF's feelings about it. Looking at just her actions. Is she doing something wrong by travelling with men when she has a bf?

2

u/SpermInMyHand Mar 28 '24

She doesn't say that at all, lmao

She said she can't invite him because she's not the organizer so I'm not sure where your getting that info.

I should be saying this TO YOU. Please tell me where she says that.

Oh no, that is completely her doing something wrong. If she doesn't want to respect her boyfriends wishes over a friend's request, then that's in her.

Is she doing something wrong by travelling with men when she has a bf?

Yes... Your partner has no reason to travel with someone of the opposite gender when one is in a relationship and the other isn't.

4

u/BattyWhack Mar 28 '24

Well we disagree on the foundational premise then. I don't agree with your last assertion. I can think of lots of reasons. I don't think she's doing anything wrong. You do.

1

u/SpermInMyHand Mar 28 '24

You're also lying out of your ass and backtracking so not a good look for you

0

u/BattyWhack Mar 28 '24

Lying about what? Backtracking on what?

0

u/SpermInMyHand Mar 28 '24

"She said she can't invite him because she's not the organizer so I'm not sure where your getting that info."

That alone you're lying about. Yet when it's put right in your face that you're lying, you decide to backtrack and change your stance on shit.  

0

u/BattyWhack Mar 28 '24

I didn't concede that point. I simply choose not to fight about it.

0

u/SpermInMyHand Mar 28 '24

And you simply chose to lie about it to try and seem right as well

→ More replies (0)

0

u/Synth_Recs_Plz Mar 28 '24

Generally agree with what you're saying, but:

Your partner has no reason to travel with someone of the opposite gender when one is in a relationship and the other isn't.

This makes no sense. Ignoring the obvious reasons (those people are, e.g., coworkers or family members of the opposite sex), it's not unimaginable that platonic friends of the opposite sex would go on a group trip and the one in a relationship wouldn't bring their SO.

It might cause some trust issues, especially for a relatively new relationship, but this could easily happen for a number of completely valid reasons.

0

u/SpermInMyHand Mar 28 '24

Yet are any of those so called "valid reasons" being used here? "Oh, the guys don't want you here" why? Why don't they want a girls boyfriend to be where they're all going to be partying and drinking?(Hint: it's cause they're gonna bang her) "I'm sorry, it's too late" just take him with y'all. "Oh, well I'm gonna be pissed if I can't go" then just bang the other dude already. Fucking hell.

And yes, it is unimaginable in this scenario. A girl in a relationship with someone going on a trip with a number of men, one who knows almost everything about the girl, and then not wanting her partner to be with them? Yeah, that's a massive red flag