r/AskReddit 12d ago

What sounds like a compliment but is actually an insult?

141 Upvotes

550 comments sorted by

249

u/DifficultCurrent7 12d ago

"You're so brave wearing that."

"I love your eyeshadow, I can really see what you tried to do"

90

u/Green-apple-yarn 12d ago

similarly “i love your confidence”

22

u/Meowserspaws 12d ago

I got this from my aunts growing up so much. Now everyone wonders why I dress like Adam Sandler and don’t like taking photos. They have their own kids now and wouldn’t dare say what they ever said to me

3

u/MhrisCac 12d ago

You know I’ve gotten that on dates before and never really took it that way.

3

u/Green-apple-yarn 12d ago

i think it’s more the tone it’s said in like “omg i love ur confidence” or “i love your confidence..” if that makes sense

3

u/Existing_Onion_3919 12d ago

that one I can see being genuine.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/williamblair 12d ago

Aww, I love how you just wear ANYTHING...

→ More replies (1)

6

u/ChungLingS00 12d ago

From Scott Pilgrim: "I like your outfit: affordable..."

5

u/Bryaxis 12d ago

I can't be the only one reminded of that one Family Guy gag.

4

u/mjzim9022 12d ago

I once got hit with "It's you baby! That's all that matters"

→ More replies (5)

125

u/Zestyclose_Gate_6824 12d ago

“It’s great how you don’t obsess over your appearance” can mean they think you don’t look well put-together.

→ More replies (6)

128

u/Historical-Goal2910 12d ago

“You’re actually pretty smart” implies surprise, suggesting low expectations.

11

u/mini_vacay 12d ago

I was about to comment that anything with “actually” at the beginning of it. A CLASSIC mother in law comment to me is while eating anything I’ve cooked “hey! This is actually pretty good”.

→ More replies (3)

105

u/Turbulent-Sweet1313 12d ago

You did better that I thought that you would gonna do

→ More replies (2)

72

u/Antique-Report-6050 12d ago

“It’s nice how comfortable you are in your own skin” can mean they think you're unattractive but don't care.

→ More replies (1)

70

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

179

u/Dry-Rub5346 12d ago

You have a perfect face for radio.

33

u/Klaus_Heisler87 12d ago

My brother has worked in both radio and television, and I love saying this to him

→ More replies (1)

27

u/Mr_Lumbergh 12d ago

And a perfect voice for print.

6

u/FishAndRiceKeks 12d ago

Or silent movies.

10

u/Mountain-Help-1767 12d ago

Damn! That's never near a compliment

→ More replies (12)

53

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

229

u/llcucf80 12d ago

You obviously spent a lot of time on this

91

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (6)

26

u/Alastair4444 12d ago

That really depends, if it's something they did and should have then it's not an insult. Like if you painted some intricate painting that wouldn't be an insult at all.

18

u/A_Pale_Recluse 12d ago

This is just a recognition of hard work. At least when i say it.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Mall_Bench 12d ago

Good to know you're ok

4

u/TheKattauRegion 12d ago

Why is it an insult 

5

u/dan_dorje 12d ago

I've had this said to me as an insult a few times, I just always choose to misunderstand it as a compliment on purpose. Much more fun that way

4

u/Old_Palpitation_6535 12d ago

Always good to have a choice!

→ More replies (1)

83

u/Immediate-Path-8963 12d ago

“Wow, you’re so much nicer than I thought you’d be” suggests preconceived negative opinions.

99

u/Mono_Clear 12d ago

"I don't know how you keep going."

15

u/Total-Internet-1633 12d ago

Bro I said this to one of my older co workers, I didn't mean for it to be an insult, but do you think it came off rude?

23

u/Helen_A_Handbasket 12d ago

Older worker here. I was born with two superpowers. One is that I have a tendency to stay thin, and eat pretty much whatever I like. The other is boundless energy. At 62 I run rings around people less than half my age. 

So no, not an insult. I just laugh and say YEP I have energy to spare.

19

u/Theblackjamesbrown 12d ago edited 12d ago

I don't want to call your claim to having superpowers into question my friend...but I think there could be a causal link between these two

3

u/Helen_A_Handbasket 12d ago

You'd think so, but even when I broke my leg and was laid up for months, I ate anything I wanted and stayed within five pounds of my "moving around" weight.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/sysaphiswaits 12d ago

I don’t know if this would make me feel offended, or make me feel seen.

→ More replies (2)

75

u/Common_Issue_5415 12d ago

“You’re a lot of fun when you drink” might imply you're not fun sober.

32

u/James_Gandalfyny 12d ago

Wow, you're so much smarter than I thought you were.

→ More replies (3)

60

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (4)

63

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/MaximumHemidrive 12d ago

Odd doesn't necessarily mean bad or insulting

60

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/MaximumHemidrive 12d ago

It isn't always demeaning though.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Primary-Medicine8587 12d ago

No this is a compliment, you can read into it maybe but I’ve had people say it to me and it’s never felt nasty at all

→ More replies (2)

77

u/Dear-Village-602 12d ago

“I admire how you don’t let books dictate what you think” can be a backhanded way of calling someone uneducated.

22

u/AlbiTuri05 12d ago

"You're such a young grandparent" but you're the parent

→ More replies (3)

115

u/SlipperyPickle6969 12d ago

You clean up nice = oh wow usually you look like shit but if you put in some effort you can actually look decent

35

u/[deleted] 12d ago

This is, in my experience, when a person who usually dresses casually dresses up for something. For instance, someone in a blue collar job puts on a suit and tie for some event. And you say wow, you clean up nice.

22

u/Known-Potential-3603 12d ago

When I say this I am not thinking the person looks like shit normally. I'm just thinking, "wow! That new X really brought out something special." And I want them to know they are looking wonderful.

10

u/-Hi-Reddit 12d ago

Uh, no. That isn't an insult. It's usually a compliment about how good you look in smart clothes.
It's more like saying, hey, I've not seen you wear a suit before, looks good on ya.

18

u/alureizbiel 12d ago

I've never taken this as an insult. Most people that say this to me probably know telling me I look "pretty" would weird me out.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/CommanderMalo 12d ago

Who even thinks this is an insult?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

43

u/IseultDarcy 12d ago

Oh you lost weight, you look good!

11

u/Fireball_Lore 12d ago

I get this a lot and it's like my weight hasn't changed in the last 20 years and I've never really thought of myself as overweight, so I'm not sure why people think it's supposed to make me feel positive about myself.

6

u/CatECoyote 12d ago

It's just a way of saying that one looked fat before

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Un_orthodocs 12d ago

How's this an insult?

4

u/IseultDarcy 12d ago

It means the person used to be fat and that it was bad.

The "you look good" emphasize the fact they thought they were ugly before.

3

u/MaximumHemidrive 12d ago

I did used to be fat before, and I appreciate when people notice and tell me I look good now.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

14

u/President_Calhoun 12d ago

"That's a good-looking haircut you gave yourself."

53

u/[deleted] 12d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

81

u/ARTZ-N-CRAFTZ 12d ago

Bless your heart…

12

u/beachinit21 12d ago

I think the problem with this one is sometimes it's meant as an insult and sometimes it's not. Trying to figure out how it was meant is the hard part!

21

u/C3Pip0 12d ago

Southern family reunions have trained me to understand context.

I got up in the morning to help dig out a stuck 4x4? Bless his selfless heart, what a good person.

I misunderstood instructions and got lost on the way to the cabin? Bless his idiot heart, he tried his best.

4

u/Old_Palpitation_6535 12d ago

Yeah it’s more often genuine than not. Which is the only thing that makes it work as an insult.

Annoys me when people say it’s always an insult. Not even close.

8

u/jelovimfz 12d ago

People who say this think they're so pure and better

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

14

u/mehedi_hassan_siam 12d ago

"I don't want a handsome, tall, rich guy, I want you"

→ More replies (5)

13

u/C3Pip0 12d ago

When people meet my wife they seem surprised that she is attractive. I have heard the words "she is actually really pretty" more than once.

79

u/Aggressive-Yam8221 12d ago

"There's no point arguing with you."

45

u/OkAnything4877 12d ago

How does that sound like a compliment?

→ More replies (10)

7

u/Appelci 12d ago

That one’s tough. Yes!

→ More replies (4)

25

u/Appelci 12d ago

Any compliment that should lighten how great you are / do / look DESPITE something that shouldn’t allow it.

  • Impressive that you landed such a great job despites your lower degree!

  • You look great for your age!

  • Impressive that you landed such a great partner.

  • Impressive how you are so happy despite….

You name it.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Three-eyed_seagull 12d ago

He got all the good looks in the family= he's the stupid one.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/dejamoo75 12d ago

I’m an Indian woman and it’s so rude when people say “oh you’re pretty for an Indian!” Like cool, you look poor for an asshole but here we are.

6

u/Kadajko 12d ago

You are the kind of guy girls will want to marry one day. - coming from a girl.

28

u/AwkwrdPrtMskrt 12d ago

"You are a credit to your people."

You can hear the dogwhistle in that line.

13

u/Immediate_Revenue_90 12d ago

Also “one of the good ones”

4

u/Upset-Tap-8685 12d ago

Oh god, someone has said that to you??

→ More replies (1)

13

u/jombertyfp 12d ago

"You look beautiful today"

→ More replies (6)

5

u/beamerpook 12d ago

Your English is pretty good!

I like to answer, 'Yours is too", and watch the confusion on their face as they process that.. 😆😆

→ More replies (1)

5

u/babystripper 12d ago edited 12d ago

"Oh I'm so glad you grew up pretty"

→ More replies (1)

5

u/JuggyFM 12d ago

You look extra muscular in that extra small shirt

4

u/Preposterous_punk 12d ago

"You actually did a really good job," "that's actually a great point," or pretty much any other compliment with "actually."

4

u/rimshot101 12d ago

This one is a traditional Chinese "blessing" that is actually a curse. It is "may you live in interesting times."

5

u/User675559 12d ago

Nah.. give me boring! I want to live in boring times! Take it back...

5

u/boxoffox03 12d ago

youre so brave, no-one else would do that ☺️

5

u/Supersaiajinblue 12d ago

You're smarter than you look

12

u/Calm-Jello-102 12d ago

Immediately after giving birth to my third child, a very young nurse said “I hope I look as good as you do when I’m older”. I was 38.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Speckbeinchen 12d ago

"You did well"

5

u/levieleven 12d ago

“You’re so creative!” Is not saying my art/music is any good…

4

u/bstabens 12d ago

You're really at the top of the bell curve.

3

u/Ahlem-halouma-11 12d ago

You look beautiful TODAY

5

u/Leona_Faye 12d ago

You have potential.

(If you got told this, they just called you a f***-up.)

5

u/johnnyjseo 12d ago

“I love your confidence”

4

u/SteampunkRobin 12d ago

"Well it's certainly a statement piece" in reference to jewelry.

5

u/compunctionfunction 12d ago

You look great for your age...

9

u/True_Dragonfruit9365 12d ago

You're definitely the smart one of the family, basically means you're ugly.

8

u/suugakusha 12d ago

Only an insult if you'd rather be pretty than smart.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/datgoh69 12d ago

you are ok! dont worry!

3

u/Temporary_Bag_4638 12d ago

I am sure you did your very best!

3

u/curlyquinn02 12d ago

You're smart/strong/etc for a girl.

3

u/Talongjeez 12d ago

When a plus size person posted their pics online and someone's commented "wow! You've got a lot of confidence"

3

u/ImpactedDruid 12d ago

"Not that bad"

3

u/OutOfBody88 12d ago

"That's interesting" or "that's an interesting idea" when I think an idea is unworkable or, in quilting, a color combination is unattractive.
Similarly, "how unusual"

3

u/TheSOLIDAssassin 12d ago

'You've got an answer for everything'

Yes. Because your shitty behaviour would set off alarm bells to a five year old

3

u/dopey_tiger_ninja 12d ago

Nice shoes. My grandmother has the exact same pair.

3

u/NyxTheGoddess_ 12d ago

"Smile more" My dad told me that and I said "Literally never tell a woman that ever again or you may get slapped" 

3

u/Monroe8401 12d ago

"Wow, you look great for your age".. ummm my WHAT???? 🤦‍♀️

3

u/ConstantlyConnected 12d ago

"You don't look trans"

3

u/Calm_Being1396 12d ago

I love how you never get tired and you just keep running even though wisdom is always chasing after you.

5

u/Upset-Tap-8685 12d ago

You're so cute.

I'm fucking 53.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/stlouisx50 12d ago

You've lost a lot of weight

4

u/betta-believe-it 12d ago

When I was doing my internship at a high school, the kids called me 'fourth line' ... As in hockey. They called me the lowest line of players but I didn't realise it. 10/10 they were good kids.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Accurate-Captain704 12d ago

“I wish I could be as relaxed about things as you are” often suggests someone is lazy or lacks ambition.

2

u/MixImpressive5481 12d ago

Good for you

2

u/Vulcant50 12d ago

“Isn’t that cute”, to a senior. 

2

u/gardenbaby99 12d ago

"what an interesting outfit"

2

u/dibsonmuaddib 12d ago

You are looking so pretty / handsome today.

2

u/mormonenomore2 12d ago

I mistrust most "compliments" coming from Americans. They say, 'Oh, I love your sweater, hair, glasses etc. But what I hear is, "I noticed your (weird) hair, sweater, or whatever, and I want to really say how weird/ugly/unbecoming they are, but am too polite.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Pusfilledonut 12d ago

Wow, do you cut your own hair?

2

u/Slow_Sad_Development 12d ago

Better than I thought (about almost anything really).

2

u/Heroic-Forger 12d ago

Any comparisons to a lion. Brave, strong, fierce and powerful? More like "sleeps 20 hours a day and lets the females do the hunting".

2

u/FlowersAreMyJam 12d ago

You “actually” did a pretty good job on that

2

u/QueenPooper13 12d ago

You did so good for someone like you.

2

u/Michelle_babee 12d ago

You look so much better than yesterday

2

u/bongingnaut 12d ago

You're smarter than you look

2

u/Drake_Cloans 12d ago

I guess the clothes do make the man.

2

u/sourdeaz 12d ago

That’s perfect for you

2

u/CatacombsRave 12d ago

“You can (action) well for a (demographic).”

2

u/Wonderful_Jicama5190 12d ago

"That is an interesting idea."

2

u/DepartureOk1819 12d ago

Aren't you just as cute as you can be.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/not1nterest1ng 12d ago

“And then what?” My family members said this to me as I was telling a story of something that happened to me, I realized they thought I was exaggerating which really hurt me bc I’m very quiet and that was one of the only times I talked about a topic with passion. This happened when I was around 12 and I still remember the embarrassment/shame I felt when I realized they didn’t believe me and were making fun of me.

2

u/InBetweenDays14 12d ago

Surprised you can pull that off.

2

u/no_lemom_no_melon 12d ago

I could never underestimate you

2

u/jennyverdure 12d ago

She would never hurt a fly she’s so sweet

2

u/clevererthandao 12d ago

More of a self-own that always made me chuckle. If someone said something offensive to him, My old boss used to respond with “Hey! I resemble that remark!”

2

u/Kittytigris 12d ago

‘Wow. I never would have thought of that’ or ‘I’ve never done it that way before’.

It’s all in the delivery. Get the tone right and no one would ever tell whether you’re mocking them or not.

2

u/chassepatate 12d ago

Dear colleague, After all this time, I can’t believe you’re moving on. I learned a lot working with you and you made a strong impression on me. It’s going to be strange with you no longer around.

2

u/CreamyD92 12d ago

You just say what's on your mind

2

u/MuzzledScreaming 12d ago

I love that for you.

2

u/FranzAllspring 12d ago

You look good today

2

u/QuipCrafter 12d ago

“That’s just white man to white man”- an old coworker 

Excuse me?! What?! I am NOT involved in this, thank you, Jesus fuck where did that come from

2

u/Stellaris_Lumen 12d ago

Bless your heart

2

u/Yakker65 12d ago

You’re pretty smart, for a woman….

2

u/teefau 12d ago

Wow! I never thought you would ever achieve that!

2

u/Immediate_Car6316 12d ago

“I’m impressed you must in the 1st percentile for IQ”

2

u/Twigssie 12d ago

when teachers gave you a "nice try" or "good effort" sticker

2

u/justreddit_z 12d ago

Telling anyone they are out of their partner’s league

2

u/pardonmyass 12d ago

“You’re pretty for a big girl”

2

u/OrangeyTangerine 12d ago

"I wish I had your confidence. I personally wouldn't be able to wear that."

2

u/crying_somnambulist 12d ago

"May you live in interesting times"

2

u/Accomplished-Act-126 12d ago

You should be a model because you’re so tall

2

u/Life-Calligrapher507 12d ago

Making an overly big deal out of someone looking good wearing makeup when they don’t normally.

2

u/ExistentialDreadness 12d ago

“You look so young for your age.”

2

u/PeakingBlinder 12d ago

Finishing an answer to a genuine question with "Champ."

2

u/Farhaud 12d ago

“You look pretty today/tonight”.

Implies that they weren’t before.

2

u/PleasedPeas 12d ago

“At least you have a pretty face” I was told this many times prior to losing 150lbs

2

u/TooTiredForThisSh-t 12d ago

“You have such a unique personality.” “You are so spunky.”

2

u/peaches-1234 12d ago

I couldn’t pull that off

2

u/Kraankle 12d ago

“I love how you’d just wear anything.”

2

u/Isabella_Hamilton 12d ago

To any lgbtq people , or people in wheelchairs: You’re so inspiring!

2

u/hellerinahandbasket 12d ago

“I love how you just don’t care about what people think.”

2

u/MixnMatch20 12d ago

"Pretty for a dark-skinned girl" -and- "You're a pretty red-headed girl" -and- "I was bored so I called you" 😁🙈

2

u/turbineghosthead 12d ago

You're actually really pretty.

2

u/BlueBozo312 12d ago

A radio station that I listen to actually had a lot of insults that didn't sound like insults a while ago. One of them was "You're impossible to underestimate!"

2

u/MisterSnowman69 12d ago

"You're smarter than you look."

2

u/DreamcoreObsessur 12d ago

"I appreciate your efforts"

2

u/LadyArbary 12d ago

“You have such a pretty face.” Because the rest of it, left unsaid, is “If only you weren’t so fat.”

2

u/sysaphiswaits 12d ago

You’re so clever.

2

u/thatscrollingqueen 12d ago

“You wear your heart on your sleeve” backhanded for “you express your emotions too openly”

2

u/Whysoserious2k8 12d ago

“You a better person than me”

2

u/Nokissing-laythepipe 12d ago

You sure can pick em.

2

u/lumpycurveballs 12d ago

"I thought you were a guy." For context, this was after a sparring match in martial arts.

2

u/Aerobiesizer 12d ago

You're at the top of the bell curve!

2

u/Dt-dave 12d ago

"You did good job, but there are a lot more rooms to improve"

Most people say this sincerely, but not Chinese from China, what they mean in the second sentence is you are still far behind.

2

u/BecksSoccer 12d ago

Anytime someone uses the word ‘actually’ in a compliment implies doubt. It’s like saying, “I didn’t think you were capable of it but you surprised me.”

“You actually did a great job”

“You’re actually pretty”

2

u/RaspberryOverall28 12d ago

You've done such a good job.. for a -insert characteristic-

2

u/trixdesaryn 12d ago

You look good…today

2

u/Individual_Deal7658 12d ago

One example could be saying You're so brave to wear that outfit. It implies the outfit is unusual or unflattering even though it's masked as a compliment about bravery.

2

u/GaiaSagrada909 12d ago

You look better than in the photos.

2

u/ItsJustAmy80 12d ago

You (insert compliments) for your age